Jun 192012
 
So you know Google will penalize anyone found selling links that directly promote or try to pass PageRank to another site if it was sponsored or sold.  You are freely allowed to link to whatever you want as long as you aren’t paid to host or embed that link.

seo search engine pagerank links thumb Does Guest Blogging Violate Google Policy on Paid Links?

Google’s Policy on Paid Links:

Buying or selling links that pass PageRank is in violation of Google’s Webmaster Guidelines and can negatively impact a site’s ranking in search results.

However, Google isn’t terribly unreasonable and clearly states on their Paid Links article in WebMaster Tools Support:

Not all paid links violate our guidelines. Buying and selling links is a normal part of the economy of the web when done for advertising purposes, and not for manipulation of search results. Links purchased for advertising should be designated as such. This can be done in several ways, such as:

  • Adding a rel=”nofollow”attribute to the <a> tag
  • Redirecting the links to an intermediate page that is blocked from search engines with a robots.txt file

This basically means bloggers can accept sponsored links and programs from services like IZEA SocialSpark and do them without any worry of getting penalized by Google.  SocialSpark always uses nofollow links for all sponsors and you don’t have to worry about the passing PageRank risk.

This also means you can leverage a URL Shortener or other pass through service that isn’t indexed if you want to have click tracking metrics to show clients for example as well.

Let’s face it though, most advertisers who want to purchase links on your site do so because they are trying to get PageRank.  This technically puts all of the following programs Intellilinks, Backlinks.com, Teliad, BlogsVertise LinkVehicle, PayPerPost, ReviewMe, SponsoredReviews, LinkWorth, PayU2Blog and others in violation of Google’s link Terms of Service even though they all require disclaimers about sponsored links, they all require “do follow” links for their advertisers which is against the Terms of Service.

DragonBlogger.com paid the price for hosting some sponsored links back in 2011 when I was testing Teliad and Intellilinks and received a warning from Google via Web Master tools that my site was being penalized for hosting sponsored links.  They drained my PageRank from 4 to 0 and it never recovered even after several PageRank updates and my removal of many links and filing for a re-review.

If you choose to sell links to advertisers from your site and they are not going to be dofollow know what you are getting into.

Guest Blogging Against Google Terms of Service?

Many guest bloggers and guest blog posts are considered violation of Google Terms of Service as well.  If any of those guest bloggers were paid by clients to put those “author bio” links in their article then hosting this article is against Google terms of service and if your site is reported you could get penalized of your Google PageRank.

broken link chain thumb Does Guest Blogging Violate Google Policy on Paid Links?I actually make a habit of asking my guest posters and nearly all who reach out to my blog are doing so because clients pay them to host links on other sites.  Now, you think Google may never find out right, after all how could they know if you didn’t know?

The thing is once 1 site is flagged for an anchor text,keyword as being a sponsored link, Google can update their algorithm to search and penalize any other site on the web hosting the same matching pattern.  This means your site could get caught in the crossfire.

Think about this when hosting guest articles where people ask for “author bio” links, if they were paid you are in violation for hosting the article.  There is no way you could know, but you still are and your site PR could be penalized if those links are flagged on another site and then scanned and found on your own site.

What is your take on this?  Do you think this makes you at risk for hosting guest articles even if you accept them from My Blog Guest?

-Dragon Blogger

 Does Guest Blogging Violate Google Policy on Paid Links?
Working in the IT Industry for over 13 years and specializing in web based technologies. Dragon Blogger has unique insights and opinions to how the internet and web technology works. An Avid movie fan, video game fan and fan of trying anything and everything new.
 Does Guest Blogging Violate Google Policy on Paid Links?
 Does Guest Blogging Violate Google Policy on Paid Links?
  • http://www.yourshop7.com/ ankit11

    very informative
     
    <a href=”http://yourshop7.com/mens-1.html”>wholesale garment suppliers</a>

  • http://www.yourshop7.com/ ankit11

    very nice
     
    <a href=”http://yourshop7.com/mens-1.html”>wholesale garment suppliers</a>

  • http://vseyewear.com/adwordsbuyfitoversunglasses.aspx Fit Over Sun Glasses

    Link-based analysis is an extremely useful way of measuring a site’s value, and has greatly improved the quality of web search.

  • Bojan Djordjevic

    I am sick of Google’s policy and being the cop on the web. I can’t stress about their bullshit, you can live even without Google. It started with me ditching Google search for DuckDuckGo.com than started migrating from Gmail… Gonna ditch their analytics, reader, webmaster tools… I am not going to support internets largest monopoly anymore.

  • seosmarty

    If you are worried about keyword-rich anchor text, simply amend your guest posting policies stating you don’t accept them. It all comes down to how high your own standards are and how well you stick to them. Guest blogging is very flexible, that’s the beauty of it.

    • guestblogposter

      @seosmarty
      We also need to put everything in perspective. Google doesn’t encourage link building because of it’s misuse in the past so as a blanket statement, they are telling people to not engage in this practice. We need to get real though, what classifies as a paid link? Is it me directly paying a webmaster for the link? Is it a client that pays an SEO firm for services knowing full well that those funds are paying the cost of the employee to build the link?
       
      I see guest blogging, whether for commercial or personal purposes as being one of the most “ethical” forms of link building. There’s nothing unethical about giving the blogger their due credit within the post. If it comes down to anchor text issues (as Ann Smarty is pointing out), then just don’t allow keyword-rich anchor text.
       
      When it comes down to it, Google cares about quality. Guest blogging can get a bad name just like any other link building method if used for spammy purposes (i.e. article networks rebranding themselves as guest blogging sites, submitting thin or spun content to bloggers, etc.) Just make sure you’re putting out great content with the user in mind and give yourself the recognition you deserve, whether that’s a link or just to get your name out there, or both.

      • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

         @guestblogposter  @seosmarty Right, the way I see it from my own experience.  Companies or Services pay X amount to have writers put guest articles on X amount of blogs with target anchor text “commercial bricks” for example.  The articles can be as good quality as any, but they are trying to get that anchor text worked into either the article (with a clever analogy so it looks fluid) or in the author bio (not quite as elegant).  Company X paid these writers, but the writers offer the guest posts for free on a bloggers site.  The quality isn’t bad so may be worth taking, but can/will Google penalize if they detect that “anchor text” is known as bought links and then penalize all blogs that host that anchor text?  Google already did this with my blog, they sent me a message on web master tools saying they detected paid links and were penalizing my PR from 4 to 0.
         
        Now, how did they know the link was a sponsored link?  If an advertiser bought a link from me directly, Google could not have known unless they flagged that anchor text somehow.

        • guestblogposter

           @Dragon Blogger Hmm… Interesting theory. I’m unsure as to how Google may have detected that you had paid links. Maybe you had a link on a site that was known for posting paid links? IMO, I would just be extremely surprised for Google to penalize others with commercial anchor text just because one company is using that same anchor text when buying links. Seems like a lot of collateral damage.
           
          Granted, nobody knows your link situation better than yourself, so you could be spot on.

      • seosmarty

         @guestblogposter I couldn’t agree more. Just provide high-quality articles and credit the author – the trick is just simple as this

        • http://www.ukhealthinsurance-services.co.uk/ John Carpenter

           @seosmarty Trust me it is really not that simple! Since the last few updates of Google, even a site like mine that is based on insurance niche are getting requests for guest blogging from other niches that really in no ways is related to each other. The propoganda that Guest Blogging works has created hell for site owners like us!
           
          What is really troubling is that when we dont rpely to them they search the whois and then they approach us, We have been getting calls for the same to..!

        • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

          Maybe it is worth paying the domain privacy feature after all :)

    • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

       @seosmarty Yeah of course bloggers can take the stance of not allowing guest posts with any anchor texts, but few would make offer content without.  Also I do see value in guest posting both accepting and promoting as a means to showcase your businesses, get attention, readership not necessarily as intention to just get author link texts for companies that pay you to get as many links on other sites as possible.  Personally, I don’t mind hosting a free article even if it has anchor text if I think it adds value or fills a gap I needed filled that week.  I just don’t need Google doing any more penalties (how much worse could they slap my blog, they already knocked me from a PR4 to PR0 for hosting links).

  • Dragonblogger

    Enough readers and users rise up and they would change, it takes the masses to affect policy decisions.

  • steaven

    Thank you for sharing your experience and facts to us,link-based analysis is an  useful way to measuring a site’s page ranking.The page ranking is based on links, Guest bloggers were paid by clients to put those “author bio” links  is against Google terms of service. 

    • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

       @steaven I am sure it is a gray area, the question is that can you be penalized and have your PageRank stripped just for hosting a guest post provided by said client who was paid to include advertiser link in their bio.  This is what I am curious about, Google clearly penalizes bloggers for hosting paid links on their site, I specifically got an email from Google saying they found sponsored links and were removing my site PageRank, though I don’t know what links they thought were sponsored, how they found out…etc.  They refused to tell me which ones so I can nofollow or remove them, with all the various guest posts I accepted over the years, I have no idea which one may have caused Google to penalize my site, or if it was hosting a link on my homepage a while back.

    • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

       @steaven I am sure it is a gray area, the question is that can you be penalized and have your PageRank stripped just for hosting a guest post provided by said client who was paid to include advertiser link in their bio.  This is what I am curious about, Google clearly penalizes bloggers for hosting paid links on their site, I specifically got an email from Google saying they found sponsored links and were removing my site PageRank, though I don’t know what links they thought were sponsored, how they found out…etc.  They refused to tell me which ones so I can nofollow or remove them, with all the various guest posts I accepted over the years, I have no idea which one may have caused Google to penalize my site, or if it was hosting a link on my homepage a while back.

  • http://www.carpetcleaningsantabarbara.net/ kathy116

    It all comes down to how high your own standards are and how well you stick to them. Guest bloggers were paid by clients to put those “author bio” links  is against Google terms of service. Thanks.

  • http://GrowMap.com/ GrowMap

    When are bloggers going to realize that Google really IS evil. They want to make sure no blogger can make a living off of blogging and put all the small businesses out of business. Their CEO ANNOUNCED their intention to “clean up” the Internet “cesspool” by favoring big brands years ago and every update they have done sense has slapped small businesses, bloggers, ecommerce sites, and competitors to all things Google. (Search SEOBook.com for that cesspool quote or ask me and I’ll provide the link.)
     
    You can’t keep on their good side any more than you can fly without being radiated or manhandled by TSA or from being stopped in a roadblock or being pulled over for some lame excuse like a dim license plate light. 
     
    Wake up already and use the influence of your blogs to change the world. Encourage everyone you know to use alternatives to Google. Quit thinking you’re going to be one of the few that joins the “haves” instead of one of the “have nots”. If you could Justin would already be rich. He’s been working at blogging since at least 2008 has high visibility and knows what he is doing. If he can’t make a comfortable living off this blog don’t think you’ll do it any faster than he has.
     
    The American Dream is an illusion we’ve all been sold – a way to keep you working yourself to death reaching for that brass ring that you can never hold on to even if you finally manage to touch it. Look around you. How many do you personally know who have “made it’. Don’t you think if it was possible you would KNOW someone? Now we have social media – how many people do you know? How many don’t have to work too hard to have a decent life never mind one of prosperity?
    There are two sets of rules: the ones for the wealthy who are not really held accountable for ANYTHING they do no matter how heinous – and rules that are used to keep the rest of us down and out. There are a lot more of us than there are of them so if more people would stop playing their tic-tac-toe games they would lose power. (Hint for those who don’t know about tic-tac-toe = you can’t win if both sides know how to play. Same reason 51 is commonly used = deck of 51 = can’t win solitaire if you’re missing ONE card.) 

    • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

       @GrowMap Many others have started blogs with different goals and focus and have eclipsed my site in both income and traffic, Ana Hoffman who runs TrafficGenerationCafe for example has 3x my income level even though her site has 1/5th my traffic monthly.  She is a prime example of someone who affiliate markets, sells and has a niche focus which works very well for her.  Brian from BlogEngage also earns enough that he can run his site full time now and live off the income as does Kristi from Kikolani who quit her job to run her site full time.  The difference is I had no intention of making blogging my full time income and job, I always wanted it to stay a hobby and I deliberately did not want to go the niche route with dragonblogger.com.  So I still think the potential for others to make a living, or at least a very good side living is there.  Do I see Internet millionaire being an option from running a blog or affiliate marketing?  No, but I see potential.  The ones who make 6 figures or more are the ones who create something, the ones who develop the WordPress plugin’s (everyone must have) or the next “Genesis or Thesis Theme that is a game changer…etc).  These are the people who have the highest potential to earn.
       
      As far as Google, I agree that their penalties for bloggers just trying to keep their sites a float and trying to pay bill is unacceptable.  However, if their system can be influenced by advertisers purchasing backlinks, that is a weakness in their system that should be fixed.  We all know Google sells ads, links themselves, so they don’t want others to be able to earn or manipulate the system unless the advertiser is directly paying them.
       
      As far as alternatives, unfortunately I used Bing, Lycos, Dogpile, every other search engine for a while and NONE produce the search results I want within the first page in most cases.  Like it or not, there is no search engine that can compete with Google for accuracy/algorithm and worse, many of the smaller ones just use Google behind the scenes anyway.

  • Chad Agrawal

    Great post on guest posting and selling links. I just got my first paid offer and I decided not to accept after reading this post. Thank you for the helpful info! You don’t bite the hand that feeds you. In this case, I play by google’s rules :-)

    • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

       @Chad Agrawal Precisely, play by Google’s rules we must.  Though I don’t oppose to charging for guest posts to ensure quality before publication, you should always watch what they try to link to in author bio.

  • http://www.techblazes.com/ techblazes

    It is the main head ache of bloggers. The day when my site got PR, some users applied for guest posting and now I have 70 contributors who are making me lazy….I also notice my blog SERP going down gradually. I thought to nofollow the links of guest authors, but I am worried that making the links nofollow of guest authors without their consent is unethical. :(

    • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

       @techblazes They will certainly come back and explain the only reason they guest posted was for the dofollow link anyway, I have heard of others using plugins that auto nofollow links on all posts older than 6 months or 1 year and this type of situation happening.

      • http://www.techblazes.com/ techblazes

         @Dragon Blogger Do you know the name of that plugin and does it makes even the internal links nofollow on older posts?

        • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

           @techblazes Try Ultimate NoFollow and see if it works for you http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/nofollow/

        • http://www.techblazes.com/ techblazes

           @Dragon Blogger Thanks for the suggestion Justin. By the way, I have stopped promoting all affiliate products and with the help of Bad Neighborhood Link Checker, I am nofollowing all the suspected sites. I will submit my site for reconsideration. Hope I get my SERP back…. 

        • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

           @techblazes I don’t think promoting affiliate products violates Google ToS, just nofollow/noindex the outbound links.

        • http://www.techblazes.com/ techblazes

           @Dragon Blogger But cloaking and hiding links does violate the TOS….

        • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

           @techblazes Noindex in robots.txt is not cloaking, it is just telling Google not to index the links, cloaking is changing the url to appear as another URL.  But that doesn’t violate the “paid links” policy.

        • http://www.techblazes.com/ techblazes

           @Dragon Blogger But Justin, in Easy Azon plugin, it has an option to cloak affiliate links which I enabled earlier…..

        • http://www.dragonblogger.com/ Dragon Blogger

           @techblazes Cloaking with noindexing and Google algorithm doesn’t see the links at all, it is like they are invisible to the search engine. So if you cloak with /go then add /go to robots.txt as noindex, then it can’t see it.

  • http://www.myeyewear2go.com/ Reading Glasses

    Someone who posts an article on a blog that is not their own. Their incentive for doing so is getting back links to increase their own site’s search engine ranking.

  • http://www.trogonsoft.com/teamwise/Recruitment_management.php Recruiting Solutions

    I saw this post at first time and its really help me in giving some knowledge about the SEO. It help me in increasing website rank.

  • jakeseo

    Did you pay fot it? Therefore it’s a paid link. Spend your time elsewhere.